This is an outdated version published on 2022-03-31. Read the most recent version.

Hard Problem of Illusion

Authors

  • Maxim D. Gorbachev Faculty of Philosophy, Lomonosov Moscow State University, 27/4, Lomonosovsky av., GSP-1, Moscow, 119991, Russian Federation.

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21146/0042-8744-2022-3-106-109

Keywords:

consciousness, philosophy of consciousness, hard problem of consciousness, illusionism, theory of consciousness, qualia, phenomenal properties, phenomenal consciousness, K. Frankish.

Abstract

The hard problem of consciousness, which consists in the need for a non-func­tional explanation of subjective experience as a possibility to have subjective ex­perience at all, while focusing on attempts to give this explanation, often loses sight of consciousness itself and its phenomenality, the real way of existence of which is assumed as a given. Illusionism replaces the hard problem of con­sciousness with the problem of illusion, which implies the need to explain how and why judgments about phenomenal consciousness are possible. Thus, illu­sionism as a theory of consciousness looks primarily at consciousness itself, tak­ing into account another possibility of explaining its existence – an illusion, a be­lief caused by the disposition to form such a belief and its formation in the course of introspective distortion of internal states during the process of their representation. That is, the internal states themselves are not illusory – they exist. But we systematically distort them. In this regard, qualia, along with conscious­ness, become an illusion, which is formed by a person based on these disposi­tions, which determine the qualitative part of our perception. Illusionism can be­come a tool for explaining not only the possibilities of qualia, but also why they are largely individual.

Published

2022-03-31

Versions

Issue

Section

Philosophy and Science

How to Cite